New research commissioned by the National Association for Healthcare Security (NAHS) highlights that healthcare security is a specialist function operating in an exceptionally demanding environment, but it lacks the national governance, recognition, training framework and organisational support appropriate to the role.
Key findings from a survey of healthcare security professionals include:
- Lack of oversight: 72% say there is insufficient national direction; only 40% have a board-endorsed security strategy.
- Aggression and Violence is commonplace: 81% reported that violence, aggression or abuse by patients occurs daily.
- Recruitment is challenging: 73% said this was the case; here, the pay relative to the threats and responsibilities was a key issue.
- Security is a specialist role but isn’t treated as such: 92% want healthcare-specific security training for all security roles, and 90% want a nationally recognised training framework.
- The operational environment is becoming increasingly demanding: misunderstanding of security’s role and powers by other staff, as well as changes such as the police response to some incidents (under ‘Right Care, Right Person’), and the implementation of Martyn’s Law, are increasing the demands placed upon healthcare security.
Professor Martin Gill, who led the research at Perpetuity Research, said:
“The striking finding from this research is not simply that healthcare security faces serious challenges, but that its role and contribution are too often misunderstood. When it works well it does much more than react to incidents: it helps create the safe environment in which staff can work and patient care can be delivered.
Our findings highlight the consequences of the lack of priority and direction since the demise of NHS Protect – inconsistency in governance, training, expectations and investment at precisely the time when demands on security are increasing.
The answer is not simply to spend more on security, but to understand how and where investment will make the greatest difference. A better understanding of the value good security creates in this environment is key.
The message from those taking part in this research is that healthcare security now needs a clearer national framework, appropriate specialist training and a much stronger understanding of its role and contribution.”
Roger Ringham, Chair of NAHS, said:
“It is important to us as a not-for-profit organisation dedicated to supporting those working in healthcare security, to take stock of the issues affecting the sector and ensure we continue to channel our energies into those that matter most.
Indeed, the findings confirm our direction of travel and in the absence of official national governance, we will continue our own work producing standards that can be used as a framework and developing specialist training for frontline officers and security leaders to create a career pathway and consistency of approach.
We will also continue to argue for Government backing for healthcare security standards to ensure healthcare organisations are obligated to give security the attention that it deserves.”
The report – ‘The Role of Healthcare Security: Addressing Key Challenges’ – was commissioned by the National Association for Healthcare Security (NAHS). The research was undertaken via a survey of NAHS members (primarily healthcare security professionals), and in-depth interviews with key stakeholders (in healthcare security and related roles/interests).

